Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Guest Column: Should You Save For College?

Students walk through the UMass Amherst campus. (Andrew Phelps/WBUR)
Students walk through the UMass Amherst campus. (Andrew Phelps/WBUR)

By Bob Hildreth

Because I founded a nonprofit organization that helps underserved students go to college, I am often asked if saving for college still makes sense. Is it smart to start saving for your child’s college education, or will your savings just be gobbled up by colleges when they’re figuring out your possible financial aid?

That’s a question that concerns many parents, at all income levels.

One low-income mother told me she had encouraged her daughter to start saving for college when she started high school at 14. Now, though, she’s not sure she did the right thing.

When the girl started working, she always deposited her $20 paycheck into a bank account her parents had opened for her. They’d planned for her to use it only for incidental expenses. But now, as they were filling out the federal financial aid form known as FAFSA, they realized that colleges would count that money toward what the girl is expected to pay.

“We didn’t know that if she had an account, that would affect you when filling out FAFSA,” the mother said. “Did we do anything wrong by encouraging her to save?”

The short answer is that saving for college expenses is always a great idea.

For one thing, studies show that children whose parents save for education have higher aspirations for college and develop a college-going identity, which leads to better grades and attendance in high school. With as little as $500 in savings, one study found, students are three times more likely to enroll in college and four times more likely to graduate – and that’s true for all income brackets.

But the longer answer requires delving into the specifics of FAFSA, or the Free Application for Federal Student Aid, and how the information on it is used to determine how much financial aid a student will be offered. Because of how FAFSA works and how colleges use the information on the form, not all savings are created equal.

Colleges and universities use FAFSA to determine eligibility for federal financial aid, so all students seeking federal aid have to fill it out. Using the information from the form, the colleges then apply a federal formula to calculate the so-called EFC, or expected family contribution: how much money the college expects the family to pay for a year of college.

If the EFC is less than the total cost of a year’s attendance, the college then decides how much financial aid it will offer. Some aid will be in grants or scholarships, which don’t need to be paid back. And some may be loans, which do.

So in order to make the best decisions about saving, families need to understand what gets counted – and what doesn’t – toward the family’s EFC. This is where it gets tricky, because different types of savings accounts are viewed in different ways.

What definitely gets counted toward the EFC are the financial assets that you report on your tax return. These include, for example, the money in your checking, savings, CD and money market accounts; any real estate investments, aside from your home; stocks, bonds and mutual funds, and 529 college savings and prepaid college plans.

And here’s what doesn’t get counted: the equity in your home if you own one, your share of any small businesses, and retirement plans such as pensions, profit sharing or a 401k, 403b, IRA, SEP, SIMPLE, Keogh, or Roth IRA plan. In addition, about $30,000 to $50,000 of the parents’ assets is set aside as an “emergency reserve allowance.”

Once those calculations are done, parents are expected to spend up to 5.64 percent of their total available assets each year to pay for their child’s college. Meanwhile, students with their own income and assets that total more than about $6,100 are expected to contribute up to 20 percent of those assets. (If they own less than $6,100, they’re not expected to contribute.)

Add the parents’ 5.64 percent and the student’s 20 percent, and that’s the EFC.

So how do student savings fit into this picture, and what is the best way to use them?

Let’s say a student had $10,000 in a savings account under his or her own name. Because students are expected to contribute 20 percent, that would add $2,000 to the EFC. But if the same $10,000 was in an account that’s considered part of the parents’ assets – such as a 529 college savings account or a Coverdell Education Savings Account – only 5.64 percent, or $564, would count toward the EFC.

So, the long answer for that worried mother may be: Yes, it was great for her daughter to save for college, but, ideally, those savings should have gone into a 529 or an ESA. Then she would have had more cash for what the family meant it for, her incidental expenses. If she’d had our hypothetical $10,000, in fact, she’d have had $1,436 more.

There’s one more twist, though: For richer families, the 529 may not be the way to go. Why? It makes the parents’ assets look larger, and that may make colleges reluctant to offer any need-based financial aid – or even merit-based aid. These families would be wise to consult a financial counselor to decide what’s best for them.

At any income level, though, saving for a college education makes good sense. And, more often than not, taking advantage of special educational savings accounts to do it makes the best sense.

Bob Hildreth, a member of the WBUR Board of Overseers and a key financial contributor to WBUR's expanded education coverage. He is the founder and executive director of Inversant. Learn more at fueleducation.org.