Our School's Rosh Hashanah Gift: The Day Off

By Linda K. Wertheimer
Through most of elementary school and high school, I had a holiday inferiority complex.
My two brothers and I were the only Jews in our rural Ohio school system, and only two holidays seemed to matter – Christmas and Easter. Vacation days were given for Christmas and Good Friday, and there was no pretense at political correctness. They were labeled Christmas and Easter vacation on the school calendars. Pastors came in and led us in prayer in Jesus’ name in annual Easter and Christmas assemblies. Teachers always wished us a merry Christmas or happy Easter.
None of my teachers or peers in the Van Buren schools acknowledged the existence of Jewish holidays, such as Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, Passover or Hanukkah. There was no mention, either, of Eid al-Fitr and Eid al-Adha, major Muslim holidays, and Diwali, the Hindu festival of lights. My brothers and I represented the only religious minority group in the school, but no one knew or seemed to want to know anything about our traditions.
Given my past, I see it as a gift that my son’s school system, Lexington, includes Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur as days off when the holidays fall during the week. This school year, on Rosh Hashanah on Sept. 14, my husband, 7-year-old son and I will spend time at temple services and with friends to celebrate the Jewish New Year. Weather permitting, we’ll walk from temple in the afternoon to the old reservoir in Lexington and toss bits of bread into the water to symbolize casting away our sins. We’ll sing, we’ll pray, and we’ll be together without having to worry that my son is missing school. By giving these days off, my son’s school system also teaches its students and staff that such holidays exist. They’re always on the school calendar.
Schools generally pick and choose which religious holidays to give off depending on a community’s religious makeup, and communities have had nasty fights over the issue in recent years largely because of prejudice toward Muslims. Beginning this school year, New York City has agreed to give two major Muslim holy days off. Only one affects the calendar this school year – Eid al-Adha, referred to as the Festival of Sacrifice because it celebrates the story of Abraham’s willingness to sacrifice his son to God. It falls on Sept. 24, the day after Yom Kippur, which New York also gives off. Cambridge for years has given Muslim holidays off.
In the town next to mine, Bedford school officials let students take excused absences for religious reasons, but students complain that they still must make up work. Many Hindu families in my town would love to see Diwali as an official school holiday. This year, Diwali falls on Nov. 11. A Hindu neighbor expressed delight that our school system gave that day off until she realized the vacation day was for Veterans Day.
Schools logistically cannot give every religious holiday off, but they can improve on what they’re doing so children, teachers, and parents understand the diversity of religions within our world and communities. One Bedford elementary school, for example, now takes pains to include various religions’ holidays on school calendars. Lexington, in response to a plea for awareness from the Indian American community, now notes Diwali on the calendar.
As a child, I was bitter that no one knew Jewish holidays. As an adult, I realize that only education can bring less ignorance and more sensitivity.
At the minimum, every public school and parent-teacher association could create calendars listing major holidays for the religions of the families among them. Jews, Sikhs, Hindus, Muslims, Buddhists and Christians of numerous denominations, including Greek Orthodox, live in my community. That way, parent groups won’t schedule all-school events on the same night as Diwali or plan a class get-together on Yom Kippur. More teachers would avoid giving tests on the days after major religious holidays for non-Christians.
My son, I know, is lucky. Not only does he get Jewish holidays off from school, but he is not the only Jew in his school, as our town has three Jewish houses of worship. I spent fourth through 12th grade living on the outskirts of Findlay, Ohio. The closest temple was roughly 60 miles away. Sure, my teachers could have asked my parents to come in and talk about Jewish holidays. But that could’ve made me stand out even more. Plus, my parents aren’t educators. The onus for education about world religions, even in elementary school, should not rest on religious minorities. I like what my son’s kindergarten teacher did. She read books about different religions’ holidays to the class.
School is not the place to celebrate religious holidays. It is the place to educate about many religions, so no child ever has to feel that one holiday trumps another.
A Lexington resident and former education editor of The Boston Globe, Linda K. Wertheimer is the author of "Faith Ed.: Teaching About Religion in an Age of Intolerance" (Beacon Press, August 2015), which looks at public schools' efforts to teach about the world's religions.