Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

'Nation's Report Card' Shows Massachusetts At The Top -- But Slipping

BOSTON -- Massachusetts students are showing gains in fourth-grade reading but are slipping in fourth-grade math and eighth-grade reading and math. That's the major takeaway from national standardized test scores released Wednesday.

While some scores are lower than in 2013, Massachusetts students still rank at the top of the nation on those tests, the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP). NAEP is often called the nation's report card because it is the only measure of student achievement given regularly to a nationwide sampling of students.

In this year's results, Massachusetts leads the nation in fourth-grade reading scores; even with its lower scores, the state statistically ties for first in fourth-grade math and eighth-grade reading and math.

Nationally, scores took an unexpected dip after two dozen years of steady increases. While critics are quick to point to new testing policies or to the Common Core standards adopted in the past five years, test administrators caution against reading too deeply into the data.

“We don’t know yet if these changes we’re talking about today are long-term.," said Peggy Carr, acting commissioner of the National Center of Education Statistics, which administers NAEP, according to the Boston Globe. "I think we need to be cautious and ... wait to see what will happen in 2017."

A statewide glance at the scores shows that large achievement gaps persist between white students and black and Latino students.

"I am pleased that Massachusetts remains the national leader on NAEP results, particularly in fourth grade reading. I am concerned, however, by the drop in eighth grade math and the low eighth grade reading results of our Hispanic students," elementary and secondary education commissioner Mitchell D. Chester said in a statement. "We will review all of our results to identify opportunities for strengthening the Commonwealth's program of instruction."

In Boston, scores rose this year, with fourth-graders for the first time ranked virtually on par with the national average in reading. In math, Boston eighth-graders caught up to the national average, finally closing what had been a 14-point gap between the district and the nation in 2003.

BPS Superintendent Tommy Chang credited the district’s consistent focus on implementing more rigorous standards and coherent curricula, as well as investments in developing and supporting teachers.

As in the state scores, however, Boston saw large gaps between students of color and their peers.

“The 2015 NAEP scores show that the Boston Public Schools is continuing to move in the right direction. However, we still have considerable work to do,” Chang said in a statement. “As Boston continues to serve as a model and leader for the nation, it is important that we maintain our focus on more rigorous standards and do everything we can to close the achievement gap and make sure our students are ready for college, career and life.”