Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Report: Schools Fall Short In Handling Students' Digital Data

In this 2014 photo, a student works on a math problem with her iPad at a Missouri school that is teaching students about legal and ethical issues online. (Jeff Roberson/AP)
In this 2014 photo, a student works on a math problem with her iPad at a Missouri school that is teaching students about legal and ethical issues online. A Massachusetts ACLU study says schools here don't do enough to protect students' privacy. (Jeff Roberson/AP)

Many Massachusetts schools are using technology to monitor students, collect personal data about them and share that data in ways that raise troubling questions about student privacy, according to a new study from the American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts.

The study, released Wednesday, examined 35 school districts across the state, including Boston, Springfield and various rural and suburban districts. Almost universally, the study found, students in those districts have "no expectation of privacy" when going online in school; many are similarly unprotected when using school-issued electronic devices, such as Chromebooks or iPads.

And many districts reserve the right to inspect those devices without notice or consent, the report said. Unlike searches of school lockers or student backpacks, the report said, in many cases school officials can search cellphones and other devices without even a "reasonable suspicion."

In addition, at least eight districts use software that can filter or monitor students' electronic activity even when they are not at school. Many use third-party applications to gather personal data that can be shared with corporations or law-enforcement agencies without the students' or parents' knowledge or consent. Only one district surveyed -- the Mystic Valley Charter School -- reported that it does not share data with third-party vendors.

The report also surveyed districts about their use of in-school physical surveillance devices. All 14 districts that responded to that question use surveillance cameras, but only one, Newton, provided a written policy on how cameras can be used, how long camera data can be stored and whether it can be shared without consent. (The districts' responses to the survey are available here.)

"Really, the critical issue is transparency," said Kade Crockford, director of the ACLU of Massachusetts Technology for Liberty Project and an author of the report. Students and their parents, she argued, deserve clear and complete information from schools on what data is being collected, whether they have the right to opt out of data collection and how that data is used.

"Privacy doesn't mean secrecy,"  her co-author, staff attorney Jessie Rossman, said in a statement. "It means having control over your personal information and the right to decide how it gets used."

In the report, the ACLU calls for new state legislation to protect students' privacy. The current law has not been updated since 2006, Crockford said, which "in terms of technology was light-years ago."

In the past two years alone, according to the ACLU, 17 other states have modernized their student privacy laws.

"Massachusetts, as a leader in both education and technology, is unfortunately far behind many other states," Crockford said. "And we really need to fix that."

Both the Massachusetts Senate and the House are considering bills that would increase privacy protections for students. Under current law, however, schools can release data without consent to "authorized school personnel," which can include the vendors that provide education software and data management -- a rapidly growing sector that was in its infancy when the law was last revised.

The state department of elementary and secondary education issued a statement Thursday in response to the report.

“We agree that student privacy is important, and we also know that schools want to ensure students are using technology appropriately," the statement said. "Most of the policies related to student use of technology are made at the school or district level. We have offered guidance in that area and will continue to look for best practices and ways to improve how schools approach these issues.”

The report also calls for strengthening the state's public records law, noting that many districts did not comply with its requests for information and, under current law, face little penalty for ignoring such requests. Of the 35 districts it contacted, the Massachusetts ACLU said in the report, six provided no records. Others would have charged substantial fees; Newton offered "very limited documentation," the report said, "and demanded $5,834 in fees to provide the remaining responsive documents."

In addition to its legislative proposals, the report offers recommendations for students, parents and administrators. These include never using school-controlled devices for personal communication, learning about the school's privacy policies and requesting a copy of student records in order to see what personal information might be shared.

Crockford said she hopes the report will "jump-start the conversation" about student privacy in Massachusetts. It's important, she said, not just to safeguard privacy but to teach students the right lessons about citizenship and democracy.

"Telling students that they have no right to privacy," she said, "is the wrong message."