Group Of Legislators Push To Remove 'High-Stakes' Nature Of Standardized Testing
Legislators critical of standardized testing are pushing five bills that could change how much sway test scores have in Massachusetts schooling. It comes just as the Obama administration is urging limits on school testing.
While the group of state legislators still want assessments that can measure students and highlight achievement gaps, their bills would remove much of the tests' current high-stakes nature -- graduation, evaluation or district ranking based on test scores.
One proposed bill would remove passing 10th grade standardized tests as a graduation requirement. Another, more comprehensive bill proposed by Rep. Marjorie Decker (D-Cambridge) would establish a three-year moratorium on high-stakes measures, which she says can punish students, teachers or schools based on low standardized test scores.
Decker's bill is supported by the state's largest teachers union.
"[The bill] removes the test as a graduation requirement, it separates it from teacher evaluations and it stops labeling our schools," Decker said at a Tuesday press conference.
Schools and districts labeled as "chronically underperforming" on standardized tests can be taken over by the state. In 2011, Lawrence Public Schools was placed in state receivership due to continually low test scores. Earlier this year, Holyoke was placed under state control due to similar circumstances.
"We already know that the greatest indicators of student achievement on the current standardized test are a student's economic background and their parents' educational achievements," said Decker.
Massachusetts schools currently use Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS) and Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC) standardized tests.
State education commissioner Mitchell Chester, who is not in favor of any testing moratorium, says data gleaned from tests is important to track student and school progress. He says test scores are just one tool used to rate teachers and districts.
"We've been very thoughtful about how we've folded our testing program into teacher evaluations and into curriculum and improvement efforts," said Chester.
State Sen. Pat Jehlen (D-Somerville) says standardized tests have not been the solution to raising the bar on Massachusetts education, citing figures that show persistent achievement gaps between students of color and their white peers.
"Standardized tests have not driven us to higher achievement," said Jehlen. "They've driven us to higher test scores, but not to higher achievement."
State officials are expected to decide in November whether Massachusetts should adopt PARCC, stick with MCAS, or use a combination of the two.