Mass. Education Chief Recommends Adding Charter Seats

BOSTON -- The state education commissioner will recommend two new charter schools and over 1,500 new seats at existing ones.
Mitchell Chester, commissioner of elementary and secondary education, announced Tuesday that he will advise the state board of education to approve new charter schools in Springfield and Brockton, plus the expansion of five existing charter schools, including four in Boston.
"These two applications and five expansions have undergone a thorough review, and I believe they will provide families with additional high-quality education options," said Chester in a statement. "I appreciate all applicants' interest in serving Massachusetts students."
The state board of education will vote on the recommendation at its Feb. 23 meeting.
The Boston schools seeking expansion include Neighborhood House Charter School and Brooke Charter Schools in Roslindale, Mattapan and East Boston. If approved, these would be the first new charter seats in Boston since 2013.
The two proposed new schools were among six finalists in this year's round of charter school applications. One of those did not submit a final application, another withdrew its application, and two more did not receive a favorable recommendation.
As for the expansion proposals, 22 schools requested an increase to their maximum enrollment or grades served, including 14 in Boston. In January, the state board approved South Shore Charter Public School's request to expand from 610 to 1,075 students. The requests that Chester has now recommended would both increase enrollment and expand the schools to serve grades K-12.
Charter proponents say charter schools provide another choice for parents not happy with traditional schools. Critics say they divert resources and erode programs at public schools.
Under current law, the state may direct up to 9 percent of the money a public school district spends on students to fund seats at local charter schools. In low-performing school districts, like Boston, the state can direct up to 18 percent of that spending to fund charter schools before it is capped. Boston bumped up against the cap in 2013.
The increase in charter seats in Boston is a reflection of Boston Public Schools’ more than $1 billion budget for the 2015-16 school year -- the district’s largest budget ever.
With more money in the district, the cap on charter spending -- and therefore seats -- rises. But a larger budget in Boston doesn’t necessarily mean extra funds. To combat widespread spending shortfalls, the public school district closed two schools, cut back food services and reduced services at the district’s counseling center last school year.
Currently, Boston schools once again face widespread budget shortfalls for the 2016-17 school year. While the state has a fund to reimburse school districts for some money sent to charter schools, the reimbursements do not fully offset the amount of money districts may give to charters -- and they're not always given.
In a presentation to the Boston School Committee in early February, officials said Boston Public Schools have lost $28 million over the past two years in unpaid reimbursements.
Dominic Slowey, spokesperson for Massachusetts Charter Public School Association, told WBUR that if the board approves the seats next week, Boston will reach its charter cap again.
The two new schools up for approval are Libertas Academy Charter School in Springfield and New Heights Charter School in Brockton. Both would serve students in grades 6-12 -- 630 at Libertas and 735 at New Heights.