As Massachusetts' Urban School Districts Face Funding Struggles, One Considers State Lawsuit

In Fall River, schools will start the fall $2.6 million in the red. Boston faces budget shortfalls that will result in the closing of two schools. Lynn Public Schools face an $18.6 million gap between available funds and the money the state requires the district to spend to provide students an adequate education. New Bedford plans to close a school to trim costs.
In Brockton, the current budget proposal includes as many as 125 teacher layoffs, and more than 60 cuts to other positions, in the wake of spending shortfalls.
Collectively, urban districts that rely on state funding are struggling in Massachusetts.
"When I'm laying off this many teachers, we are looking for solutions in a large urban district," said Kathleen Smith, Brockton's superintendent of schools. "And I'm out of solutions."
Poverty, Fluctuating Populations Challenge Urban Districts
Smith says challenges associated with three main factors disproportionately affect urban districts' spending: costs associated with educating and transporting homeless students; English-language learners; and a state funding deadline of Oct. 1.
Currently, school districts must submit their Oct. 1 population as the basis for funding from the state. For urban districts across the state that see a high rate of mobility in the district, this can mean a difference between the number of students figured into state aid and the number of students actually being taught in the district.
Brockton had 17,186 students enrolled as of Oct. 1. Since then they've gained 206 students this school year. Students may be transfers from other districts, transfers from charter schools or recent immigrants, but they all have one thing in common -- none are considered in the district's state funding until the next school year.
"I won't see funding for those students for almost 18 months from that October 1st date," Smith said. "Sometimes we have up to 400 new students registering."
Like the spending shortfalls, transient students are common across urban centers in the state. As of June 1, Lynn Public Schools gained 656 new students, New Bedford gained 221 new students, Lawrence Public Schools gained 234 new students and Fitchburg Public Schools gained 173 new students.
"We rely very heavily on the state for funding for our students. Almost 80 percent of our funding is picked up by the state," Smith said. "Our tax base isn't what it needs to be to support education, at least equity in education."
Urban Students Disproportionately Absorb Funding Gaps
In 2013, according to the most recent data from the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education, 22 school districts spent less per student than the amount the state determined is needed to provide students with an adequate education.
All but nine of them serve urban students.
Urban school districts, Smith says, are "under assault" by a funding formula that does not give them enough money.
So Smith and Brockton school officials this week began talking about levying a new "equity lawsuit" against the state because of what they see as inadequate funding to urban schools.
Brockton School Officials Consider Lawsuit
Although the state is in the midst of analyzing the school funding formula, Smith isn't shying from the possibility of a lawsuit -- a notion not foreign in Brockton.
Follow the trail of education reform lawsuits in Massachusetts and they often lead back to one place: Brockton Public Schools.
Most famously, perhaps, was the 1978 Robyn vs. Secretary of Education lawsuit named for a third grade Brockton student that led to the 1993 Education Reform Act. The act ushered in MCAS exams, charter schools, major classroom changes and, most notably, a new framework for local school districts to receive state aid known as Chapter 70.
And in 2003, Julie Hancock, another Brockton student, challenged that funding formula -- citing overcrowding and a lack of resources in her school -- in a case that went to the Supreme Judicial Court.
Now, it looks like Brockton could be at the forefront of another push through the courts to challenge district's funding.
"The Chapter 70 formula is no longer supporting our very, very needy students and, I'm sure, other urban districts and Gateway Cities in the way that it needs to," Smith said. "We are prepared to meet this summer and start to talk about our options."
Correction: An earlier version of this article incorrectly stated the number of districts serving urban students that spent below foundation budget in 2013. The correct number is nine. We regret the error.