Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

U.S. Report: Mass.' Revised Method To Track Student Poverty Is Insufficient

In order for measures of student socioeconomic status to remain consistent, a National Forum on Education Statistics guide recommends measuring student eligibility for state programs in combination with collecting data directly from student families. (David Goldman/AP)
In order for measures of student socioeconomic status to remain consistent, a National Forum on Education Statistics guide recommends measuring student eligibility for state programs in combination with collecting data directly from student families. (David Goldman/AP)

BOSTON -- A federal guide for education agencies that outlines ways to identify student socioeconomic status says that Massachusetts' new method to track student poverty is not sufficient on its own.

As we reported Tuesday, Massachusetts has scrapped a decades-long practice of using free or reduced price lunch eligibility as a measure of student income. Instead, a student is now termed “economically disadvantaged” by the state if the student receives specific public benefits, including food stamps or foster care.

As a result, the number of students identified as poor has fallen dramatically.

The guide, released Monday by the National Forum on Education Statistics, offers Massachusetts' new method as one way to measure socioeconomic status, but says given the method's limitations, it should be used in combination with other measurements.

Why The Measurement Matters

The new measurement has been turning heads in the state, as the official numbers of poor students in districts plunge.

For instance: Of Massachusetts' 22 cities with populations over 50,000, most saw their count of low-income students -- who formerly made up a majority of the city district -- plummet to less than half, with the new measurement.

In Boston, the number of students who are identified as poor has been reduced from three-quarters of the district to less than half. Revere's measurement of poor students was cut by more than half: 37 percent now qualify as poor, down from 78 percent.

Dr. Paul Dakin, superintendent of Revere schools, believes the new state methodology leaves no room for families who have not tapped the welfare programs -- either out of pride, lack of knowledge, incorrect applications or their legal status.

"I know that more of our kids are children of poverty, they're just not being picked up by the various state agencies that are providing data to the state," Dakin said in an interview.

Documented immigrants are not eligible for food stamps until they have lived in the country for five years, although children under 18 are. Undocumented immigrants are not eligible to participate in any state-administered programs but, Dakin said, the district still has a legal obligation to educate them.

He sees the change in measurement as having possible long-term effects on districts' federal funding.

"Heavy poverty communities receive grant funding to be able to address the issues of poverty that come with educating children," Dakin said. "It could cost districts hundreds of thousands of dollars in grant money."

The Boston Globe editorial board echoed those sentiments in a recent editorial.

An inaccurate calculation of student poverty will eventually leave financially strained schools vulnerable to funding cuts. It ought to be a priority for state education authorities to strengthen their methodology for finding and counting the poor. In an age of ubiquitous data, it’s critical for the Commonwealth to pinpoint our neediest populations.

Guide Recommendations

In order for a measure of student socioeconomic status to remain consistent with the historical methods of measurement, the National Forum on Education Statistics' guide recommends using student eligibility for programs in combination with collecting data directly from student families.

Although the guide was produced by the Forum, an organization created by the U.S. Department of Education's National Center For Education Statistics, the information does not necessarily represent federal education policy.

Michael Hopkins -- the superintendent of schools in Rochester, New Hampshire, who helped to craft the guide -- said simply analyzing student families' enrollment in state programs as a measure of school district poverty can present challenges.

"It doesn't necessarily capture everyone because they may not qualify or want to qualify or need to qualify, but they still probably are still socioeconomically disadvantaged," Hopkins said.  "You want some consistency and not just whether they fill out the paperwork and apply for the state program."

Instead, the guide recommends using that measure alongside asking families to fill out forms that verify a student's or family's income, as well as identifying and taking into account students who are homeless, migrants or runaways.

Combining the three measures, Hopkins said, would provide a more accurate snapshot of students' socioeconomic status than any measure could do alone.

The impetus for the new guide is the same reason that Massachusetts officials set out to create a new way to measure student income: School districts across the country, including Boston and 21 other Massachusetts districts, participate in a federal program that offers free meals to all students, regardless of income.

The program, which was designed to eliminate stigmas associated with free lunch and remove a level of overhead costs for districts where a majority of students qualify, has made meal eligibility data a less accurate indicator of student socioeconomic status.

In its wake, Hopkins said the education community has a unique opportunity to implement a more accurate measurement that takes multiple factors into account.

"The more information you have, the better your source is," he said. "If you're just using one source, and free and reduced lunch was just one source, you aren't getting all the information you need."

This post was updated at 3:07 p.m.