Mass. Senate Unveils New Charter School Bill Tying Cap To State School Funding

By Steve Brown
With a ballot question aimed at raising the cap on publicly funded charter schools looming this fall, the state Senate has unveiled a bill that would not only raise the cap, but also seeks to address funding concerns for traditional district schools.
The senators who drafted the proposal say it not only increases the cap on charter schools, but also puts district schools and charter schools on a level playing field. They say the proposed ballot question addresses the needs of less than 10 percent of the state's public school children.
In announcing the plan, Senate President Stan Rosenberg said the Senate is looking beyond just charter schools.
"What we were seeking to accomplish through this exercise was to step back and do what we would call a 20-year review and revise exercise based upon the work that was done to provide choice in education, to create excellence in education here in the commonwealth of Massachusetts, which started in 1993 with the education reform act of that year," Rosenberg said.
The main provision of the Senate bill ties the charter school cap lift to fully funding the state's foundation budget for all public schools, both charters and traditional schools. That's estimated to be an extra $1.4 billion over a period of seven years.
Senate Ways and Means Chair Karen Spilka, one of the four senators who drafted the plan, says it helps all students.
"This bill makes the commitment that when we are talking about all of our children, it is very clear, and very simple -- we are really talking about all of our children here," Spilka said. "And it does set forth a path to fund it. It is doable, it was done previously."
The bill also tightens up controls on charter schools, requiring them to publicly disclose finances and discipline policies, among other things.
Teachers at charter schools would have to be certified, and charter schools would have to fill empty slots should they become available throughout the school year as some students leave the charter.
There would be no cap on charter schools that specifically serve at-risk students, and the bill gives flexibility to educators in underperforming traditional districts to introduce more innovative approaches in the classroom.
While the Senate is hoping the bill satisfies both charter school proponents and opponents, backers of the referendum are disappointed. Marc Kenen of the Massachusetts Charter Public School Association says the bill will not provide relief to the 34,000 families proponents say are now on charter school waiting lists.
"This in fact will freeze the growth of public charter schools," Kenen said. "It will impose new regulations on existing charter schools that will make it that much more difficult for us to continue to offer the high-quality options that we do."
While withholding specific comment on the Senate bill until he's had a chance to read it, Gov. Charlie Baker, who has backed the lifting of the charter school cap, says he wants students still on charter waiting lists to attend a high-quality school.
"The vast majority of the families we're talking about here can't afford to send their kids to private school," Baker said. "They can't afford to move. They need the schools in their community to perform on behalf of their kids and when you have 34,000 kids on waiting lists, mostly located in low-income communities and communities of color, and you have a solution that has proven to be successful, over two decades now, I think we can do better."
Senators will likely discuss their proposal at an upcoming caucus, with a debate and a vote on the bill expected sometime next week.